Não foi possível enviar o arquivo. Será algum problema com as permissões?
Diferenças
Aqui você vê as diferenças entre duas revisões dessa página.
| Ambos lados da revisão anterior Revisão anterior Próxima revisão | Revisão anterior Próxima revisão Ambos lados da revisão seguinte | ||
|
artigos:ernesto1 [2007/01/05 14:22] ernesto |
artigos:ernesto1 [2007/01/08 08:12] ernesto |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Linha 67: | Linha 67: | ||
| Figure 2: Variables in the X axis are specified in the legend but not in the figure | Figure 2: Variables in the X axis are specified in the legend but not in the figure | ||
| + | |||
| Linha 74: | Linha 75: | ||
| 1. There's a paragraph (lines 325-332) justifying the use of a log transform, in particular in lines 330-332 is mentioned that the log was found on previous analysis of the historical data. | 1. There's a paragraph (lines 325-332) justifying the use of a log transform, in particular in lines 330-332 is mentioned that the log was found on previous analysis of the historical data. | ||
| - | 2. Acho que temos que clarificar este parágrafo (lines 241-253). We agree with the referee comments and adjusted the text to clarify it. convergência & estimativas dentro dos parâmetros iniciais. | + | 2. We agree with the referee comments and adjusted the text to clarify it. The key issue was that the convergence was good and the parameters estimates were within the range of the initial parameters, so the simulations could be trusted for the following work. |
| 3.1 We generalized our results for all species that fit in the range of the covariance parameters used. This may not apply to invertebrates but certainly apply for most demersal species, which are the target of our survey. This sentence was revised to clarify it's aim. | 3.1 We generalized our results for all species that fit in the range of the covariance parameters used. This may not apply to invertebrates but certainly apply for most demersal species, which are the target of our survey. This sentence was revised to clarify it's aim. | ||
| Linha 80: | Linha 81: | ||
| 3.2 The autocorrelation structure in the data is presented in Table 1 where all the correlation parameters estimated are shown and in lines 231-240 we describe them and the most important particularities found. | 3.2 The autocorrelation structure in the data is presented in Table 1 where all the correlation parameters estimated are shown and in lines 231-240 we describe them and the most important particularities found. | ||
| - | 3.3 We used two different species with very different aggregation behaviors, hake an ubiquitous species and horse mackerel a more schoolastic species, and both species present quite different life traits. We believe these two entangle characteristics that are quite extreme within our target species, although we can not guarantee that other species in specific years would not present correlation structures that are outside the range choose. (++??) | + | 3.3 We used two different species with very different aggregation behaviors, hake an ubiquitous species and horse mackerel a more scholastic species, and both species present quite different life traits. We believe these two entangle characteristics that are quite extreme within our target species, although we can not guarantee that other species in specific years would not present correlation structures that are outside the range choose. |
| Minor comments ok ! | Minor comments ok ! | ||
| Linha 117: | Linha 118: | ||
| From the Editor-in-Chief : | From the Editor-in-Chief : | ||
| One reviewer asks for relatively small changes, while the other feels the paper is not acceptable unless it is substantially shortened and focused on what is new. If the authors will react to the reviewers comments , I will reconsider the assessment. | One reviewer asks for relatively small changes, while the other feels the paper is not acceptable unless it is substantially shortened and focused on what is new. If the authors will react to the reviewers comments , I will reconsider the assessment. | ||
| - | |||
| ====Versão revista==== | ====Versão revista==== | ||
| Linha 125: | Linha 125: | ||
| {{artigos:fish896.tar.gz|EJ: 05/Jan/2007}} {{artigos:relatorio-diff.pdf|Ficheiro diff}} | {{artigos:fish896.tar.gz|EJ: 05/Jan/2007}} {{artigos:relatorio-diff.pdf|Ficheiro diff}} | ||
| - | {{artigos:relatorio.lyx|ficheiro LyX]] --- //[[ernesto@ipimar.pt|Ernesto Jardim]] 2007/01/05 14:20// | + | {{artigos:relatorio.lyx|ficheiro LyX}} --- //[[ernesto@ipimar.pt|Ernesto Jardim]] 2007/01/05 14:20// |
| + | |||
| + | {{artigos:revised2.lyx|Revisado por PJ}} --- // 2007/01/05 18:20 (LX)// | ||
